The problem behind the brief can make all the difference, but only as well as it's defined
Before you improve the message, test the assumption about why it is needed. Five questions can change a communication brief while there is still time.
A research team wants a short animation. Enrolment in its voluntary air-quality monitoring project is low, and the brief says people need a clearer explanation of how the project works.
That might be right. It is also a diagnosis disguised as a deliverable. Before drawing the first storyboard, someone needs to ask what evidence shows that understanding is the obstacle.
The difference matters because a polished explanation can succeed at its own job while enrolment stays low. People may understand the study and have no time to take part. They may be unsure how their data will be used. They may disagree with the questions the study has chosen to ask. Each account suggests a different assignment.
The theory inside the request
Most communication briefs contain a causal story, even if nobody writes it down: people are not doing X because they do not know Y; if we explain Y, they will do X. The story is useful when it fits the evidence. It becomes costly when the team treats it as a fact.
This is not a reason to dismiss explanation. A 2026 systematic review by van Stekelenburg and colleagues examined 178 publications using the “deficit model” of science communication. The authors found that the term covers such varied assumptions that broad verdicts about it are hard to test. They argue for informing and empowering people to use scientific information. Their proposed model is a research agenda, not evidence that information alone will resolve every participation problem. [1]
The practical task is more precise: find out whether missing information is the limiting condition in this project. A brief should state that as a question to investigate, rather than burying it in the requested format.
Five questions to take into the briefing meeting
These questions are a proposed professional diagnostic, not a validated five-step model. Their purpose is to make the commission’s theory visible early enough to change it.
1. What response are we trying to understand? “Engagement” is too elastic to diagnose. For the air-quality project, does the team mean visiting a page, signing up, collecting a sample, or remaining involved for six months? Write down the action and the point at which people stop. A video view is evidence of exposure; it does not answer why a person did or did not enrol.
2. What makes us think understanding is the barrier? Ask what people have actually said or done. Can prospective participants explain the project’s purpose and still decline? Do they ask the same procedural question repeatedly? A short comprehension check, an interview about a real decision, or observation of the sign-up process may be more informative than a general satisfaction survey. If the evidence points to a confusing consent form, the animation brief may need to become a consent-design brief.
3. What would a willing, informed person still need in order to act? In our hypothetical project, sampling equipment might be available only during working hours, or the instructions might assume access to a suitable outdoor space. Those are possibilities to test, not claims about a real study. If access is the obstacle, changing collection arrangements may matter more than explaining them again.
4. What might people reasonably question? A person could understand the sampling method yet ask who owns the measurements, whether results will influence a local decision, or why their neighbourhood was selected. A RAND Europe review commissioned by Wellcome distinguishes trustworthiness from simply being trusted. It identifies expertise, integrity, benevolence, transparency and responsiveness as relevant qualities, drawing mainly on evidence from Europe, the US and Canada. The review does not diagnose this Australian project, but it shows why a more authoritative script cannot substitute for an answer about governance or motives. [2]
5. Who can act on what we learn? Before commissioning the asset, agree what happens if the research reveals a service, policy or relationship problem. Who can alter the sign-up process? Who can explain or change the data arrangements? Who can respond if residents object to the project’s priorities? Without a route back to those decision-makers, audience research becomes a way to collect concerns that nobody is empowered to address.
When the answer changes the assignment
There is a temptation to make “more participation” the automatic answer to a weak brief. That would simply replace one untested theory with another. In an online experiment with 725 participants, Momme and colleagues examined involvement in designing a science article. Active involvement improved perceptions of a scientist’s benevolence and integrity, but not perceived expertise or message credibility. Participants selected from predefined design choices in a fictional scenario; the experiment did not test whether a real organisation changed its decisions or whether enrolment improved. [3]
Participation is worth designing for a defined purpose. If the project needs to learn whether its chosen research question matters locally, invite people into that decision while there is still room to change it. If the issue is a hard-to-find instruction, test the instruction. If the issue is equipment access, fix access. If people understand and choose not to take part, respect that choice and assess whether the project can still meet its aims.
A revised brief might still commission the animation. It would now have a narrower, testable job: explain the sampling process to people who want to consider joining. The project team would separately address access, data use and the questions it has asked the community. Evaluation could check whether the animation improves understanding, while enrolment and continued participation are interpreted alongside those other changes.
The most useful sentence in the first meeting may be: “What evidence would change this brief?” If the answer is “none”, the team has already decided what the problem is. If the answer is specific, communication can begin with a better question.
Sources
[1] van Stekelenburg, A., Schaap, G., Veling, H., Buijzen, M. and Fransen, M. L. (2026). A systematic review of the deficit model and call for empowerment toward informed publics. Annals of the International Communication Association, published 31 August 2026. Systematic review and proposed model.
[2] Milne, R. and colleagues, RAND Europe (2026). Public Trust in Science: Overview Findings on Trust and Scientific Trustworthiness. Commissioned by Wellcome, June 2026. Evidence synthesis and exploratory social-media analysis.
[3] Momme, J. M., Hendriks, F. and Enzingmüller, C. (2025). From Participation to Trust? Understanding Trust Dynamics in Participatory Science Communication. Science Communication, first published online 24 April 2025. Online experiment.
