Is the hidden work your message asks of your audience too much for them?
Clear information matters. Effective communication also requires understanding whether people can act, what they trust and what changing course would cost them.
A message can be clear and accurate while asking more of its audience than they can realistically give. Better communication begins by finding that hidden work.
Imagine a council preparing a campaign to improve food-waste separation in apartment buildings. The proposed animation explains which scraps belong in the collection bin. The team wants residents to understand the system and use it correctly.
Now follow one resident beyond the final frame.
They watch the video on the train. At home, they need somewhere to keep scraps, an agreement with their flatmates and access to the building’s collection area. They also want to know whether separated waste is actually processed as promised. By collection day, remembering the instructions may be the easiest part of the task.
This is a hypothetical example, not an evaluation of a real council programme. Its value is in exposing a question that can disappear inside a communication brief: how much work must people do after receiving the message?
For organisations communicating science, public policy and sustainability, that question offers a more useful starting point than assuming a clearer explanation will resolve disappointing participation.
A campaign brief might say “increase awareness of the new service”. A more revealing brief would describe the action: a resident separates scraps, stores them appropriately and deposits them in the correct shared bin.
That description makes the surrounding conditions visible. It invites the team to ask where the process becomes confusing, inconvenient, socially awkward or difficult to trust.
The COM-B Model for Behavior Change provides a foundation for this diagnosis. In their 2011 paper, Susan Michie, Maartje van Stralen and Robert West describe behaviour through interacting conditions: capability, opportunity and motivation. These include knowledge and skills, the external environment, and both deliberate and automatic processes such as intentions, habits and emotions. [1]
The distinction matters because someone can understand an instruction, support its purpose and still face conditions that prevent action. COM-B helps organise that investigation; it does not establish which obstacle dominates in a particular building or community.
The UK Government’s behaviour-change guidance, updated on 13 October 2026, translates this into a practical boundary. Communication can influence knowledge and motivation, while shortages of time, money, tools or access generally require a response beyond messaging. The guide also recommends considering whether a different actor has the power to remove the barrier. [2]
In our imagined apartment building, that actor might be a building manager responsible for access to the collection area. A resident-facing video could be excellent while a separate conversation with the manager remains essential.
The hidden work begins before anyone reaches the bin. A person first has to encounter the explanation, recognise its relevance and retain enough to use it later.
The Australian Communications and Media Authority’s 2026 news-consumer segmentation research offers useful context. Its survey covered 5,590 Australian adults in June 2025, alongside 35 qualitative interviews. It identifies seven audience segments and describes news habits shaped by convenience, familiar sources and time constraints. Sustained comparison and verification demand effort. [3]
This concerns news consumption, rather than the effectiveness of public-service campaigns. The relevant editorial inference is to investigate how an explanation functions during a brief encounter, rather than assuming every reader will explore its supporting material.
For the hypothetical campaign, the team could test whether residents can find the essential instruction on a sign beside the bin. Would the audience be more engaged with an animation if they watched it at the moment of putting the waste in the bin? A longer animation accessed by a QR code sticked on the bin could explain the process and answer all the questions. Detailed information could support residents who want to investigate further.
These formats would have different jobs. Their usefulness should be tested at the moment each is meant to help, rather than inferred from the polish of the finished production.
Suppose residents ask whether separated scraps really reach the promised processing facility. The team should investigate what lies behind that question before interpreting it as resistance.
There may be missing information. There may also be a service failure, an inconsistent explanation or a previous experience that makes the question reasonable. Each possibility calls for a different response.
The ethical task is to establish what can be demonstrated and explain the remaining uncertainty. If the service is failing, the communication team needs a route for escalating that finding.
This is consistent with an important caution in John Besley and Jennifer Metcalfe’s 2026 science-communication conference review. They describe research discussions questioning the pursuit of unwarranted trust and emphasising transparency and critical engagement. Their article is a conference review, rather than a controlled test of communication practice. It nevertheless provides a useful reminder that trust deserves scrutiny as an objective. [4]
Some barriers involve relationships rather than facilities. In our hypothetical household, one resident might be enthusiastic, another sceptical and a third concerned about smells. Participation requires a shared arrangement, not simply individual comprehension.
A related perspective comes from Syed Umer Ahmad Qadri’s Epistemic Authorisation Filter, published in September 2026. The framework proposes that misinformation becomes difficult to revise through interacting effects of timing, source legitimacy and the social or identity costs of changing a belief. [5]
It is a conceptual framework with predictions for future testing. Applying it to our household example would be an interpretation, not a finding established by that paper. The useful question is whether the communication makes reconsideration possible without turning disagreement into a public contest over who was wrong.
For Redboat, these sources suggest a practical contribution before production: help the client describe the action, follow the audience’s path and identify where effort or uncertainty accumulates. This is an editorial synthesis, rather than a newly validated method.
In the imagined campaign, useful questions would include whether residents understand the sorting rules, whether the facilities are usable and whether the processing claims can be substantiated. Conversations and observation could help distinguish these explanations before selecting the response.
Evaluation could then follow the diagnosis. Understanding checks would assess the instructions. Access checks would assess the facilities. Participation and contamination measures could assess the overall system. Views and clicks would describe exposure while leaving those other questions open.
This approach also gives communicators a stronger basis for discussing responsibility. The animation has a defined contribution. Service design, building access and operational delivery have contributions too. The brief can identify who needs to act when evidence reveals a problem.
The most useful outcome of audience research may therefore be a changed assignment: a shorter instruction, a better-positioned sign, a more transparent account of the service or a conversation with someone who controls access.
Before asking how to make a message more compelling, follow the person who receives it. What must they notice, remember, arrange, trust and negotiate before anything changes?
Sources
[2] UK Government Communications. The principles of behaviour change. Updated 13 October 2026.
[3] Australian Communications and Media Authority (2026). News consumer segmentation research.
[5] Qadri (2026). The Epistemic Authorization Filter: Windows, Gates, and Costs of Misinformation.
